top of page

By Freddie Rotman

In the winter of 1905, the Jewish community of St. Petersburg was in turmoil. During the first year of the Russian Revolution, a wave of bloody pogroms swept across the Russian Empire, and the tsarist authorities seemed to have no objection to the violence against the Jewish population. Jewish students, outraged by the Romanovs' position, decided to organize a protest rally in one of the capital's large halls. Representatives of various political movements gathered: from Social Democrats to Bundists, from Communists to Zionists. However, the hall soon descended into chaos that threatened to turn into a fight. Marxists clashed with Zionists, and the chairman of the meeting failed to restore order.

Three people stepped forward to restore order. One of them was the future famous historian Max Soloveichik, the second was Vladimir Jabotinsky, who later became the leader of Revisionist Zionists. The third was Jabotinsky's friend, a law student at St. Petersburg University, Victor Kugel.

Kugel and Soloveichik lifted Jabotinsky onto their shoulders. Rising above the audience, the future leader of revisionism shouted "Basta!" (Enough!) – and everyone immediately sat down.

It's unknown what influenced the audience – was it Jabotinsky's authority? Or the height to which his comrades had lifted him? Victor Rafailovich Kugel, nicknamed "one and a half Jews" by his university companions for his gigantic height, could calm any troublemaker by his mere presence.

Unfortunately, the role of this outstanding personality in the history of the Jewish national movement has been practically forgotten, which we will gladly try to rectify.

Victor Kugel was born on February 15, 1884, in Mozyr, Belarus, into the family of state rabbi Rafael Mikhailovich Kugel and housewife Khanna Vigdorovna Rabinovich. Victor was Rafael Mikhailovich's son from his second marriage. Besides performing his direct duties as a state rabbi, his father owned a small printing house in the city and ran a Russian language school for Jews. He believed that even religious Jews needed to keep up with the times and acquire modern knowledge, including the official language of the state in which they lived.

Victor studied not in his native Mozyr, but at the Sumy gymnasium. After receiving his certificate, he moved to Kharkiv, where he enrolled in the university to study law. Like many of his peers, the young man was captivated not only by sciences but also by revolutionary romanticism. For participating in anti-government student unrest, Victor was even arrested and expelled from the city by the police several times. But his thirst for knowledge prevailed, and student Kugel would return to his studies.

In 1905, thanks to a stroke of luck, Victor Rafailovich was able to move to study in St. Petersburg. Transferring to the capital's university was not easy for a Jew, but his half-brother, a popular journalist, helped. While interviewing the St. Petersburg governor-general, he dared to ask for a personal favor – permission for his younger brother to transfer to the St. Petersburg Imperial University. The governor-general unexpectedly agreed.

In Petersburg, the law student became even more involved in politics. His heart was turned toward the historical homeland of the Jewish people – Eretz Israel. It was there, as Jewish leaders said, that a solution to the Jewish question could be found. Victor Kugel agreed with this position and threw himself completely into the Zionist movement.

From November 21-27, 1906, Victor Kugel participated in the Third All-Russian Zionist Congress in Helsingfors (as Helsinki was called then), where Russian Zionists formulated the idea of "synthetic Zionism" – combining settlement activities in Palestine with active political engagement in Russia.

In St. Petersburg, the young man had to not only study but also earn his living. Fortunately, his half-brothers Alexander, Osip, and Iona had already established themselves in the city. Together with them, Victor began publishing magazines that quickly gained popularity. Victor Rafailovich worked as a secretary for the "Theatre and Art" magazine. Simultaneously, he managed the publishing houses of "Satirikon" and "Blue Journal."

While actively participating in the Zionist movement, Victor Kugel also engaged in publishing works by Jewish authors. For example, in 1906, he published a separate brochure featuring a story by Joseph Perelman (writing under the pseudonym Osip Dymov) about Jews hiding in a cellar during Jewish pogroms. The story was aptly titled "Pogrom." In the same year, Kugel translated and published David Pinski's drama "Days of Pogrom," as well as a work by Avrom Rozin, one of the leaders of the Socialist Jewish Workers Party, titled "The Jewish Question as Viewed by K. Kautsky and S. N. Yuzhakov." Following this, he printed Otto Krause's "Socialism and Zionism," translated from German, at Volpin's lithographic printing house.

Gradually, Kugel's affairs prospered, and his publishing work brought in good income. In 1908, he married Maria Abramovna Shmulevich, his fellow countrywoman from Gomel, and two years later, their firstborn son was born, whom they named Rafael, after his grandfather.

Jabotinsky was a frequent guest of the Kugels, often visiting Victor Rafailovich and Maria Abramovna with his wife, Anna Markovna, and son Eric. Kugel had another close friend – Joseph Trumpeldor. At one time, Trumpeldor even courted Maria Abramovna's sister, Eda Shmulevich, but was rejected. It was said that the reason was the injury Joseph received during the Russo-Japanese War.

When World War I broke out, Victor Rafailovich didn't join the army due to his very poor eyesight. In 1918, when Petrograd became quite unstable, he left for Crimea with his wife and son Rafael. The Kugels had a summer house in Balaklava.

Victor planned to emigrate to Palestine from Soviet Russia but didn't manage to do so. He remained in Crimea. When the Bolsheviks arrived there, he began working in various newspaper editorial offices and the printing department of the Crimean Council of National Economy. In 1922, he was invited to Moscow: the State Publishing House of the RSFSR was being established and needed first-class specialists.

Throughout the 1920s-30s, Victor Kugel was engaged in publishing activities. His last workplace was the Scientific Publishing Institute of the Great Soviet World Atlas under the USSR Central Executive Committee, where he held the position of production consultant.

However, in June 1931, he published a book "Essays on Publishing and Printing," and a scandal suddenly erupted. A devastating review appeared in the "Paper Worker and Printer" newspaper, signed by two unidentified pseudonyms. The reviewers were little concerned with professional issues, but noting the absence of a party definition of the role of the press, they denounced Victor Rafailovich's book as "opportunistic and class-hostile." The tone of the review made it clear: Soviet authorities had marked old specialists and would not tolerate dissent.

Indeed, Victor Kugel never abandoned politics. Maintaining connections with Palestine, Victor Rafailovich was among those who continued to promote the establishment of a Jewish state in Eretz Israel within the Soviet Union.

Around 1930, Kugel's acquaintance, Mark Efimovich Bronstein, who had once worked with him at the State Publishing House, suggested he join a group called "Algemein-Zion." Victor Kugel, who never hid his attitude toward Zionism, supported the idea. Soon, the well-known Moscow doctor and equally passionate Zionist Joseph Kaminsky joined their group. Someone named Sasha, a man about thirty-five years old and a member of the Zionist Labor Party, also took an active part in the organization.

Meetings usually took place at Victor Rafailovich's apartment or at Joseph Kaminsky's place. During these meetings, they talked extensively about Palestine, the latest news from Jewish Yishuv life, and read materials from the "Davar" newspaper and other Palestinian publications.

The group members had a very negative attitude towards Soviet power. How could it be otherwise, when the country banned teaching Hebrew and forcibly detained people who wanted to leave for Palestine? Moscow Zionists rejected the idea of creating a socialist-based Jewish analog to Palestine within the Soviet Union – the Jewish Autonomous Oblast in Birobidzhan. It was clear to everyone that this was an attempt to distract Jews from solving their problems and exile them to one of the most remote corners of the USSR.

In 1933, at one of the meetings, the Zionists decided to publish a bulletin. Previously, the Central Committee of the Zionist Labor Party, represented in the "Algemein-Zion" group by Sasha, had distributed its own bulletin. He took charge of all organizational and technical aspects of the publication.

It was decided to sign the new bulletin on behalf of the "United Merkaz of Zionist Organizations in the USSR." According to the general decision, the bulletin was to contain exclusively Palestinian chronicles. The Central Committee of "Algemein-Zion" planned to distribute information about the construction of the Jewish homeland in Palestine among Jews. But later, articles of a more general nature began to appear in the bulletin. Kugel and his companions also counted on the emergence of Zionist groups in other USSR cities.

From this point on, Victor Kugel and his associates effectively assumed the functions of the central body of Zionists throughout the Soviet Union, which was supposed to coordinate Zionist activities locally. They also sought to inform the Yishuv about the situation of the Jewish population in the USSR.

Soon, on behalf of the "merkaz," Victor Kugel established contact with Joseph Rosen, director of the Agro-Joint corporation. He visited him at his home on Spiridonovka Street. From him, he received money sent from Mandatory Palestine three times, which he passed on to Sasha. The entire sum of 12,000 rubles was sent from Tel Aviv by Benjamin-Hertz West, a representative of the Zionist Labor Party who had moved to Palestine in 1924. The money was intended to help political exiles. This was substantial assistance: a liter of milk, for example, cost about 3 rubles at that time.

In 1934, Boris Moiseevich, a fellow countryman of Victor Kugel, joined the Moscow Zionists. Kugel only learned the surname of this elderly religious Jew – Deksler, a photographer at Moscow Sports Equipment Factory No. 1 – during the investigation. He was also later arrested by the NKVD. Deksler introduced the underground members to young religious Jews who also wished to work for the benefit of their people.

Working underground under Soviet rule for a long time was practically impossible, so Victor Kugel was mentally prepared for arrest at any moment. He even developed an action plan in case people in peaked caps showed up. One late evening, there was a ring at the Kugels' apartment. Victor Rafailovich rushed into the corridor and threw a bundle of papers into the room of a neighbor in the communal apartment. The alarm turned out to be false. Apologizing to the angry lady, Kugel retrieved the Jewish Agency bulletins in English from her room. He used these bulletins to prepare materials for his own publication. His son helped with translating from English.

In the summer of 1934, an important event occurred. David Baazov, a prominent Zionist from Georgia, came to Moscow. Victor Kugel, Sasha, Joseph Kaminsky, and Boris Deksler met with Baazov at the National Hotel. At the underground Zionist meeting, they discussed Boris Deksler's trip to Ukrainian communities, as well as the question of creating a real "Zionist center," convening a general Zionist congress, and expanding active underground work.

At the meeting, it was noted that the "United Merkaz of Zionist Organizations in the USSR" created by Victor Kugel and several of his associates was not authorized to represent the views of all Soviet Zionists in Palestine and generally "showed weak activity." Whether weak or not, the work of Victor Rafailovich and his associates was noticed by "those who needed to notice it."

In early 1934, Kugel was summoned to the GPU. He was tasked with writing an article about USSR Jews, supposedly intended for publication abroad. A couple of days later, Victor Rafailovich gave his son a draft to read. The son was horrified: his father had openly expressed his true thoughts about Soviet policy on the Jewish question. Kugel rewrote the article to align with the official viewpoint. But this didn't help.

Uninvited guests arrived at the Kugels' home on the evening of October 28, 1934. The Jewish activist's son and daughter were at home. After presenting a warrant, the Chekists began their search. About two hours later, Victor Rafailovich and his wife returned home. Two more individuals arrived to assist the Chekists and also began reviewing papers. By morning, the search was complete, and Victor Rafailovich was taken to Butyrka prison.

Victor Kugel didn't hide his political beliefs. During one of his first interrogations on October 30, 1934, he confirmed that since 1902, he had been close to the Zionists, believing that the Jewish question could only be resolved by establishing a territorial center for the Jewish people in Palestine.

According to the interrogation protocols of those arrested in the case of the "United Merkaz of Zionist Organizations in the USSR," the "organs" were quite well-informed about the underground activities. The mysterious Sasha, who carefully concealed his surname and true role from his associates, frequently came up in the investigators' questions.

It wasn't difficult to guess his role. One Sunday, shortly before Victor Kugel's arrest, this same Sasha came to his home on Trekhprudny. The man followed Victor Rafailovich through the room past the dozing St. Bernard, Gibor, who in ten years of living with the family had never paid attention to strangers when family members were present. This time, however, Gibor suddenly jumped up and lunged at the frightened visitor with furious barking. He clearly sensed danger to his master in the stranger. But the master himself suspected nothing.

On February 15, 1935, Victor Rafailovich was sentenced by a Special Council of the USSR NKVD to 5 years of imprisonment for counter-revolutionary Zionist activities.

On March 14, he was sent by convoy to a camp in Potma, Mordovia, and by early October, he was moved even further – to Ukhtpechlag in the Komi Autonomous Region. Since prisoners were transported through Moscow, his son and wife managed to see Victor Rafailovich at Yaroslavsky Station. The visit lasted two hours under guard supervision. Victor Kugel arrived at the Ukhta-Pechora corrective labor camp on October 2, 1935. As an educated person, the convicted Zionist was assigned to work as an accountant in the camp. Most likely, he had a chance to survive and be released.

However, a terrible outcome came two years later. The savage Stalinist regime moved to directly eliminate its enemies, both imagined and real.

In late December 1937, Victor Kugel was arrested again in the camp. During interrogation conducted by the 3rd Department (the operational Chekist department within the camp administration structure) of the Ukhta-Pechora corrective labor camp on December 25, 1937, Victor Rafailovich maintained true dignity. Refusing to falsely accuse two fellow prisoners, Turyansky and Nemirovsky, who were designated as his "accomplices," the prisoner categorically rejected accusations of a counter-revolutionary conspiracy within the camp. However, neither confessions nor evidence were needed: the executioners disregarded even their own laws.

For religious propaganda and counter-revolutionary agitation, under Articles 58-10 Part I and 58-II, the NKVD Troika for the Arkhangelsk Region sentenced Victor Rafailovich Kugel to death by firing squad. The sentence was carried out at the special regime camp point Novaya Ukhtarka. The brave Zionist and honest man died on March 29, 1938.

In July 1938, his son, worried about not receiving letters from his father for a long time, managed to get an appointment with the prosecutor. The unfriendly man listened to Rafail Kugel, looked at a folder on his desk, and for some reason inquired about his father's health condition. The son responded. After brief consideration, the prosecutor announced: "Your father died from a brain hemorrhage." Allegedly, Victor Rafailovich died in the camp on May 15, 1938.

The lie was uncovered only decades later. On November 10, 1989, Victor Kugel was rehabilitated based on Article I of the Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR from January 16, 1989, "On Additional Measures to Restore Justice for Victims of Repressions that Took Place During the 30-40s and early 50s."

Most of those involved in the case of the "United Merkaz of Zionist Organizations in the USSR" were destroyed by the system. One of the few survivors was that very same Sasha, a provocateur for Soviet security. In her memoir, Faina Baazova, wife of Georgian rabbi David Baazov, reveals Sasha's real surname – Gordon. Indeed, there was a witness with such a surname in the case – one Gordon Grigory Semyonovich. When Jewish life began to revive in Moscow after the war and the persecution of "rootless cosmopolitans" began, "Sasha" was repeatedly seen near the Moscow Choral Synagogue. He tried to strike up conversations with synagogue congregants and gain their trust.

...
Many blank spots remain in Victor Rafailovich Kugel's biography. But even now, we can say with complete certainty that this courageous man deserves a place in the pantheon of Jewish heroes. He was destroyed, but neither subdued nor broken.

05.04.2022



Bibliography and Sources:


Kugel, V. R. Essays on Publishing and Printing. Moscow: OGIZ, 1931.

"Materials from Archive Case No. N-9.263 regarding V. R. Kugel." Central Archive of the FSB RF [Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation].

Tsensiper, Aryeh Leib, and ʻEver Hadani. Paʻame ha-geʼulah: sefer ha-Tsiyonut ha-Rusit me-reshit "Ḥibat-Tsiyon" ʻad mahpekhat 1917. Tel-Aviv: N. Ṭversḳy, 1951.

Kugel, Rafail. "Life and Death of My Father." The Seventh Day, 18-20.

David, Itzhac. תולדות יהודי קווקאז בארץ ישראל [History of the Caucasian Jews in Palestine]. Tel Aviv-Yafo: קווקאסיוני, 1982.

Photos provided by Natalia Sogolovski, great-granddaughter of Viktor Rafailovich Kugel.

Victor Kugel

1884 – 1938

bottom of page